I was browsing the Facebook page of a prominent school of Dehradun on which a ex student (now in her 60ties ),had put up two photographs
of the school she had studied in during the sixties .And inevitably the word
nostalgia found its way into the photographs captions .Nothing new .We all put
up photographs of the schools we studied in .And we all want to flaunt its rich
heritage and its distinguished alumni .The response was also expected –a flood
of teary eyed comments ,about the teachers ,about the friends and about the
passing away of so and so .!!Again nothing new .
But the question still remains –why do we respond so
powerfully to a collective memory of something which we never liked so much at
the time we were in it ?Schools then ,(and let me be honest even now ) were
always a symbol of something that was
not a joyous experience to go through .It led to a movement which propagated
that if a child likes to go to a school –then it’s a good school,irrespective
of whether he learnt anything there or not .Otherwise –it’s a bad school .!But years down
the line all stressful memories get washed away and the one memory that keeps
haunting you is –“school was wow .I wish
I could go back to it .Oh –what would I not give to be taught by Mr G.C .Gupta or
Mr J.L. D’Souza”.!!Why ?
I think its partly because as human beings we get
“selective” about our memories .We tend to select the great moments of our life
–and we have plenty of them in school .
Psychologists also propound the theory that the recall factor
is the strongest when we are young .In other words –the further one goes into
the past ,the stronger are the memories .Which is interesting because one would
expect that what happened in the near past should be clearer in our memory than
something that happened lets say about 40 years back .But in practical terms it
does not work like that. .At least as far as I am concerned –I have very vivid
memories of what happened when I was a school boy and less of them what happened to me lets say about 5 years
back .The result –we connect with what we can remember ,and schooldays are the
strongest connect ,because they go as far as one can get as one ages .
Apart from what psychologists say ,I think there are certain
other factors which make school days chil always special .No matter what one goes
through –childhood is always associated with your dreams .Its a special quality
that a child has –to dream .To dream and enjoy it –you
have to be be a child or as innocent as a child .The entire school
system was based on selling you dreams .I remember writing a essay “if I could
fly”.!!And I remember reading a fairy tale of “Thumbelina”,and “Jack and the
beanstalk”.!! I remember acting in “Cindarella”as Prince Charming in “Cindarella”.
I remember asking my mother once as to why people die .She
tried to handle it in a simple way by saying “People die when they stop
breathing”.But why would people want to stop breathing ?I vowed not to stop
breathing ever ,and so much so that when I saw my mother in coma, and everyone around
me was telling me that i must be “brave”,I just saw no reason for it .I went near her still body ,and
could see her breathing .I was convinced that everyone was being unduly
pessimistic . Innocence
(like foolishness ),has a joy .I don’t know whether I was foolish –but I
promise you that like many schoolboys ,I was innocent .As I grew up –it kept
getting diluted in my quest to be successful .
While in school we dream of our future .In a uninhibited way
.I wanted to be truck driver .Why would anyone not want to be a truck driver
?One got to drive endlessly ,one did not have to switch off lights at 9 pm and
go off to sleep ,one need not take the compulsory afternoon nap between 3 to
4pm and one could eat food at any place on a highway .There were wonderful
dhabhas as we drove with my dad on the Dehradun –Delhi Highway and while we
stopped at them for a cold drink or a hot cup of tea ,I could see the drivers
of the trucks just lie on the charpoys and gorge into wonderful dhabha food .I
wanted to be a truck driver .I never understood why father scowled at me .But as a schoolboy no one could
stop me from dreaming .Thats another matter that I was not allowed to chase
them .
Years down the line my thought processes got “corrupted”.I
started eyeing jobs that were “status” oriented and which would fetch me money
.And it got more “corrupt” when my son started doing a course at college
.”Economics” was the mantra .Why ?Well you can crack either the IAS ,or the CAT
,or you could do research and become a Professor at a American University
.!!You could also become a investment banker or work with the World Bank .You
could go to the London School of Economics or the London Business School
.!!After all –he is my only child !!So life has become very complicated now .But
as a school boy –those days –no one ever thought in such a complicated way .
Another reason for glorifying your schooldays is perhaps the
fact that one is in great health when one is in school .The deterioration sets
in gradually –the niggling pains ,the increase in blood pressure ,the increase
in blood sugar ,the high cholestoral level ,the odd operation ,the nightmare of
the ICU ,a heart attack ,-these are things one never thinks of when one is in
school .And yet –these are things which obsess people as they age .We get
worried about the bulging belly and the hips ,we get worried about the streaks
of grey as they start to show and we get horrified to see the crows feet near
our eyes .Oh God –schooldays were so lovely .!!
And perhaps the most important reason for loving our
schooldays is the fact that we are more equal in a school than in any other place where we gather regularly to
work in life later .True there is a
difference between children who do well in studies and the others-but then that
gets offset by children who do brilliantly in debates or games or music etc .Or
by someone who is hopeless in everything else –but has great looks .He was the
guy all the girls were mad about .And girls in school never think like girls in
college or in jobs –how much money does this guy have and after 10 years what
rank will he be holding .!! The reason for liking someone was looks and the
persons ability to care for you .For me it still is .!!
As we move on in life ,we get into more and more complicated
formulas about how to live it .And frankly speaking I don’t understand half of
them .I was recently at the Secretariat of a state where my school mate is the
Chief Secretary .In between conversations with me ,he was attending to some
visitors as well .And most of the time he was talking stuff which I could not
understand . “No no Mr Duggal ,how can he be junior to you” he said
“Sir , because he is drawing less salary than me”,replied Mr
Duggal .Made sense to me –but not to the Chief Secretary .
“Mr Duggal ,but he is in a higher scale than you”, and
things were getting complicated now .Scales ?
“But Sir ,his grade pay is less than mine”,replied Duggal .I
switched off .!!When he left my friend looked at me and said
“He has a problem of pay fixation .Thoda sa complicated
hai mamlaa”.!!And then replied
“Yaar Kulu ,there were no complications when we were in
school .I remember you were in Ranjit House and I was in Ashoka House and all
of us had the bun and samosa at the tea break .!!”he said
“And you came first in Class ,while I was the Headboy.But
remember Amar Sharma the good looking guy .?We envied him as he had all the CJM
girls running around him.And he had played Under 19 Cricket for India .”I replied .And then after a time I said
“Sadly ,he passed away a few years back in Mumbai .Too much of drinking –too
much of smoking”
“Yes”,replied my school mate . “At the end of the day ,death is the
greatest leveler.Baki
sab democracy ke fundey bekaar hai .(All other Fundamentals of Democracy
are fake)We are all equal that way”,he said
“And perhaps we are more equal than ever again while we are at school .We pay the same fees
,we wear the same uniforms ,we are taught by the same teachers ,we have the
same type of classrooms ,and we have unlimited and uninhibited dreams .No one
can tax us on that”,I replied .
Maybe that’s the reason why we glorify schooldays.It helps
us to forget the sharp inequalities that
overtake our lives as we grow older.No one likes to live in a system in which
one feels privileged at the expense of the others .And maybe that’s why we love
going back for reunions .You are still known by your school numbers and your
school houses .And the talk will inevitably veer around to incidents that took
place many years back .A reunion in which people are talking about Indo Pak
relations or about Anand Kejriwal –is not a school union . A reunion is a
resurrection of our past and our dreams .Not all of them worked out –but at
least I am glad I dreamt them .!!
Dear Sir, I like you article and it really attracts the mind. I wanted to add something to "Just do what u enjoy and not what people think is enjoyable .!!". Even before we understand what we enjoy or can enjoy, the conditioning has already been done on us. We are told that we are boy/girl, son/daughter etc etc. We are not told scientifically that when we die and we go to another body or not. Simply blowing on the boil work is being done by giving, will work answers.We are not given the education to understand the real self. We could really choose a enjoyable path, if we know or knew our real self. Given the first truth we are told is not true, all our decisions based on that truth to enjoy are also not true. We end up in misery and not so happy. All our efforts to be happy will not work, unless we get the basics right. A fish cannot be happy without water, does not matter which car you give it travel.
ReplyDeleteRegards,
Shashi
My 9.5 yr old son talks of designing & building rockets whereas my 6.5 yr old daughter wants to drive an icecream truck ...she says she would eat the good flavors herself & would only sell the ones she doesnt like much ...talking of childhood dreams...
ReplyDelete